Home › Forums › Recent American History › Brazil getting a nuclear sub
- This topic has 5 voices and 8 replies.
-
AuthorPosts
-
Phidippides
KeymasterNow why, pray tell, would Brazil need a nuclear submarine? What kinds of international threats has Brazil received? Is this good because the U.S. now has another ally with a strong navy, or is it bad because the U.S. has a new threat in the southern hemisphere?
“We can say that with these installations we are entering the select club of countries with nuclear submarines: The United States, Russia, France, Britain and China,” said Rousseff.
http://www.france24.com/en/20130301-brazil-get-its-first-nuclear-subs-0
DonaldBaker
ParticipantIt's a prestige thing I would think.
skiguy
ModeratorAmazing what Olympic and Soccer World Cup money can buy these days. Maybe they want to nuke Venezuela or Argentina.
Aetheling
ParticipantBrazil just want to stay a developed and sovereign country. Why can't they do that ?
Phidippides
KeymasterSo they need a nuclear submarine for that?? Granted, I am not up to speed on Brazil's role in geopolitics, but I was unaware that it had any major foreign enemies. Perhaps Venezuela?
scout1067
ParticipantBrazil just want to stay a developed and sovereign country. Why can't they do that ?
I have to agree with Aeth here. If Brazil has the means why can;t they join the club. Tjhey are not a threat to the US and West. If anything they are another member of the club. It is not like they are coming out of nowhere with this. You guys do know that Brazilian troops fought with the Allies in Italy in WWII don't you?
Phidippides
KeymasterI have to agree with Aeth here. If Brazil has the means why can;t they join the club. Tjhey are not a threat to the US and West. If anything they are another member of the club. It is not like they are coming out of nowhere with this. You guys do know that Brazilian troops fought with the Allies in Italy in WWII don't you?
My original post was not a claim that Brazil was not justified in obtaining a nuclear sub, but instead a question of why, and whether it was good or bad. I am not particularly persuaded by the argument of “why not?”, since there are some pretty good generic reasons why the proliferation of more advanced military hardware around the globe is not a good thing.
DonaldBaker
ParticipantBelieve it or not guys Brazil is going to be a major player in the new global economy in the coming years. They are clearing the Amazon rain forest at an amazing pace which will greatly increase their industrial output. Brazil is also rich in natural resources and their political situation seems to be stable. Brazil is planning on taking on a greater role in world politics and this is good news for the United States since we cannot shoulder the burden alone anymore.
scout1067
ParticipantBelieve it or not guys Brazil is going to be a major player in the new global economy in the coming years. They are clearing the Amazon rain forest at an amazing pace which will greatly increase their industrial output. Brazil is also rich in natural resources and their political situation seems to be stable. Brazil is planning on taking on a greater role in world politics and this is good news for the United States since we cannot shoulder the burden alone anymore.
+1
skiguy
ModeratorThey already are.
-
AuthorPosts